Translate
Subscribe to Blog via Email
Ronny Allan
Background
I’d never heard of Serotonin until I was diagnosed with Neuroendocrine Cancer in 2010. It is frequently discussed, often with contrasting views from the respondents. One common assumption/question is that it is responsible for many things that can go wrong with Neuroendocrine Cancer patients who have serotonin-producing tumours. To a certain extent, that’s true but statement such as “it’s the hormones” is an easy assumption to make; or an easy answer to give in response to a complex set of circumstances. It’s difficult to get a definitive answer and the science behind the behaviour of our hormones isn’t really 100% tied down – the human body is extremely complex.
You may see serotonin referred to as a ‘neurotransmitter’, a ‘chemical’ and a ‘hormone’ – this is complex, but it is my understanding that it can add context in respect to the role/location of the serotonin, e.g. neurotransmitter is concerned with the central nervous system and the brain (the neuro in neuroendocrine), whereas chemical and hormone are essentially synonymous with the endocrine system. The two systems interface thus the term “Neuroendocrine“. Consequently, I’ll keep this as basic as I can (author’s note on completion – it was not easy!).
One more issue I frequently see is the assumption that all Neuroendocrine Cancers are hormonal via Serotonin which is patently not correct. Serotonin is only one hormone involved in Neuroendocrine Cancer and is almost exclusively associated with the group of tumours once known by the ancient and misnomer term ‘carcinoid‘ thus the term ‘carcinoid syndrome’. However, the misuse of the term by doctors, advocate organisations and patients, spreads the myth that anyone who is symptomatic with Neuroendocrine Cancer has carcinoid syndrome and/or oversecretes serotonin, leading to unnecessary testing, worry, confusion and potentially unnecessary treatment. This adds to the issue I intend to cover below.
Serotonin and NETs
One thing which is widely accepted and agreed…… Serotonin is definitely involved in Neuroendocrine Tumours, particularly those resulting in carcinoid syndrome which can manifest as a number of symptoms including (but not limited to) flushing and diarrhea. Although serotonin is one of the main ‘hormones’ released in excess by certain NETs (mainly midgut), it is not thought to be the main culprit behind some of the symptoms produced by Carcinoid Syndrome. For example, flushing, the most common symptom (and a cardinal one) is thought to be caused by a number of hormones/peptides – too many to list but the main ones are histamine (particularly foregut), tachykinins (Substance P), bradykinins, prostaglandins. However, it does appear to be guilty in causing carcinoid syndrome diarrhoea, desmoplasia, and carcinoid heart issues.
How does Serotonin get into our bodies?
Serotonin’s technical name is 5-hydroxyltryptamine (5-HT). It is converted from 5-Hydrotryptophan (5-HTP) which is also known as oxitriptan. 5-HTP is a naturally occurring amino acid and chemical precursor as well as a metabolic intermediate in the biosynthesis of serotonin from Tryptophan (often known as L-tryptophan) which is an amino acid (protein building blocks). L-tryptophan is called an “essential” amino acid because the body can’t make it on its own. It must be acquired from food. This makes Tryptophan very interesting as that brings in one of the missing pieces of the jigsaw – food! Tryptophan cannot be manufactured in the body; it must be brought in via diet. It follows that there is no serotonin in food (incorrectly stated on many websites), it is only manufactured in the body via the complicated process just described. In simplistic terms, after absorbing Tryptophan from food, our bodies convert it to 5-HTP and then to serotonin, but it’s also involved in generating melatonin, and vitamin B6 (nicotinamide). Additionally, a small amount of Tryptophan is converted to B3 (Niacin) – the importance of this will be described later. Changes in the level of serotonin in the brain can alter mood. Melatonin is important for sleep and vitamin B6 is essential for energy metabolism
While serotonin cannot cross the blood-brain barrier, tryptophan can, and once there, almost all of it is converted to serotonin. Unlike, peripheral serotonin where only a small percentage is used to generate serotonin. Just to emphasise that NET dietitians do not say to avoid foods containing tryptophan other than at the time of marker testing (see below and nutrition Blog 4). When you look at the role of tryptophan in the manufacture of brain serotonin, this might have an adverse effect if there is insufficient tryptophan generated (see Serotonin and the Brain section below).
Tryptophan in food enters the body and serotonin is created by a biochemical conversion process that combines tryptophan (essentially a protein) with tryptophan hydroxylase (TPH), a chemical reactor. I suspect other substances might be involved in that process. There are two forms of tryptophan hydroxylase – TPH1 and TPH2, which are encoded on two independent genes. TPH1 is linked to peripheral serotonin while TPH2 is related to brain serotonin. This is the process exploited by Telotristat Ethyl (XERMELO) which is a drug able to help with the symptoms of Carcinoid Syndrome diarrhea (not adequately controlled by SSAs) or where patients are unable to be treated by somatostatin analogues for whatever reason. It’s a potent inhibitor of TPH which will disrupt the manufacturing of tumour-derived serotonin. Read about Telotristat Ethyl (XERMELO) here.
Tryptophan and Serotonin – the smiling assassins?
It should also be noted that the precursor to serotonin, tryptophan, does pass through the BBB and it is therefore possible that tryptophan depletion in the gut and brain can lead to less availability of serotonin in the brain. There are two potential issues:
1. Tryptophan depletion can be caused by dietary restrictions i.e. lack of tryptophan foods. When tryptophan stores are low in the brain, they cannot be converted to serotonin. which may then cause lower availability of serotonin needed to carry out its brain function of regulating mood etc. It follows that foods containing tryptophan might be important for those with consistently elevated gut serotonin levels (except when testing 5HIAA when they are omitted from diet during testing (read more here). See below for some of the dangers of taking 5-HTP or Tryptophan supplements if also taking anti-depressants – always consult your NET Specialist in such matters.
2. The over-secretion of serotonin can lead to less availability of tryptophan. In carcinoid syndrome, functioning tumour cells indirectly depress niacin (B3) production by diverting tryptophan metabolism towards making serotonin and away from niacin. Malnourishment and diarrhea, frequently present in carcinoid syndrome patients, reduce the availability of niacin by decreasing the amount ingested and absorbed. In extreme cases, the decreased availability of niacin eventually results in very low niacin levels responsible for the development of a skin condition called pellagra. For this reason, many NET Dietitians recommend a Vitamin B supplement (e.g. B Complex)
Due to a number of advancements in diagnosis and treatment, in particular, the introduction of somatostatin analogues which help with hormone regulation, these issues are less common but NET patients with highly elevated 5HIAA should remain vigilant to the possibilities.
Measuring Serotonin levels
Measuring levels of serotonin is important in both diagnosis and management of certain NETs – although it’s probably sensible to test all potential NET patients during diagnosis when the type of tumour is not yet known. Testing for tumour markers will differ between countries and within countries but the most common standard for testing Serotonin appears to be 5-HIAA (5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid) either via a 24-hour urine test or via a plasma version (mainly used in USA but now creeping into UK). 5-HIAA is the output (metabolite) of 5-HT (Serotonin).
5HIAA should not be confused with the less reliable ‘serum serotonin’ which is a different test and can be affected by a number of things including the use of anti-depressants (read here about this – a paid article but I wanted you to see the headline). I know many people also test for raw serotonin but many NET specialists say it’s an unreliable test given that serotonin levels are really just a ‘snapshot’ at one time and serotonin is known to spike throughout the day. Your doctor will normally request measurement of 5HIAA in a 24-hour urine collection in the first instance, with serotonin measurement being reserved for cases where the 5-HIAA result does not help. Urine 5HIAA is preferred because it is more stable and, since it is collected for 24 hours, there is more chance of identifying increased 5HIAA concentrations than excess serotonin that is only released intermittently. The 5HIAA blood version is also snapshot but it’s still reliable because the serotonin has taken time to convert to 5HIAA and so spikes of serotonin have been smoothed out to produce an accurate result.
It’s hard to diagnose a serotonin imbalance in the brain because there’s no way to accurately test the amount. Blood serotonin levels don’t necessarily reflect the levels in your brain. It also has to be remembered that serum serotonin and 5HIAA are not absolute tests, they are simply indicators of a potential problem.
I intentionally did not mention the other common test (Chromogranin A) or other markers as although there can sometimes be a correlation and rises and falls, they are measuring different things, but you can read about in my Testing for Markers blog.
Read more about 5HIAA by clicking here or on the picture below.
Serotonin and the Brain
There is constant discussion and assumption that serotonin-producing tumours are somehow causing depression, anxiety, and rage. Not as simple as that and I wrote a totally separate article here focussed on brain serotonin. See “Serotonin – it’s a no-brainer!“
Summary
I did say it was a difficult jigsaw!
Disclaimer
I am not a doctor or any form of medical professional, practitioner or counsellor. None of the information on my website, or linked to my website(s), or conveyed by me on any social media or presentation, should be interpreted as medical advice given or advised by me.
Neither should any post or comment made by a follower or member of my private group be assumed to be medical advice, even if that person is a healthcare professional.
Please also note that mention of a clinical service, trial/study or therapy does not constitute an endorsement of that service, trial/study or therapy by Ronny Allan, the information is provided for education and awareness purposes and/or related to Ronny Allan’s own patient experience. This element of the disclaimer includes any complementary medicine, non-prescription over the counter drugs and supplements such as vitamins and minerals.
Top 10 Posts & Pages in the last 48 hours (auto updates) (Click the titles to read them)
Thanks for reading.
Personal Facebook. Like this page please.
Blog Facebook. Like this page please.
Awareness Facebook Like this page please.
Sign up for my newsletters – Click Here
My Diagnosis and Treatment History
Check out my online presentations
Check out my WEGO Health Awards
Check out my Glossary of Terms – click here
Please Share this post for Neuroendocrine Cancer awareness and to help another patient
A Spotlight on Neuroendocrine Cancer Syndromes – Carcinoid Syndrome
What is Carcinoid Syndrome? Carcinoid syndrome (CS) is the most frequent hormonal complication accompanying neuroendocrine neoplasms (NENs) and is defined by chronic diarrhoea and/or flushing in the
Somatostatin Receptor Positive Advanced Bronchial Neuroendocrine Tumors – PRRT vs Everolimus
I was delighted to see this clinical trial which looks at the efficacy of PRRT (Lu177) vs the efficacy of Everolimus (Afinitor). The latter is
Opinion: Let’s attack Cancer metaphors
Since I started blogging, I’ve read dozens of articles on the subject of ‘cancer metaphors’ and in particular their use in describing cancer experiences with
A review of November 2023 on RonnyAllan.NET – Living with Neuroendocrine Cancer
November is always busier as I help spread awareness for 10th Nov (remembering that every day is 10th Nov on my site!). I also managed
European Neuroendocrine Tumor Society (ENETS) 2023 guidance paper for Digestive Neuroendocrine Carcinoma
This ENETS guidance paper, developed by a multidisciplinary working group, provides up-to-date and practical advice on the diagnosis and management of digestive neuroendocrine carcinoma, based
Neuroendocrine Cancer – Clinical Esoterica
One of the key awareness messages for Neuroendocrine Cancer is the hormonal syndromes that can often accompany the diagnosis for many people. As it’s a
Neuroendocrine Cancer – The F Words
When I first created my blog in April 2014, I had to find some material to lead up to my 84 mile walk (at the
Laughter is the best medicine
Laughter is important. This is a remastered version of one of my early blog posts. It centred on a ‘get-well’ card I received recuperating in
European Neuroendocrine Tumor Society (ENETS) 2023 guidance paper for gastric neuroendocrine tumours (NETs) G1–G3
The ENETS 2023 guideline for gNETs are combined with the guidelines for Duodenal NET (dNET) due to their close relationship in anatomical terms. Gastric neuroendocrine
A cup of tea
I would also mention those who contributed to my “Tea Fund” which resides on PayPal. You don’t need a PayPal account as you can select a card but don’t forget to select the number of units first (i.e. 1 = £4, 2 = £8, 3 = £12, and so on), plus further on, tick a button to NOT create a PayPal account if you don’t need one. Clearly, if you have a PayPal account, the process is much simpler
Through your generosity, I am able to keep my sites running and provide various services for you. I have some ideas for 2023 but they are not detailed enough to make announcements yet.
This screenshot is from every single post on my website and depending on which machine you are using, it will either be top right of the post or at the bottom (my posts are often long, so scroll down!)
Ronny, Have been on Somatuline gel since 1993. ( first three times/day then long acting release) Have only just found your info. Any other long term users? M Roberts
Yes thousands of people!
Ronny, I experienced extreme symptoms of anxiety, depression and anger while my Carcinoid Syndrome was going on. I am not as technical in my description of things as you but, these symptoms immediately ceased after debulking and removal of primary tumor. The doctor’s explanation of this was that my tumor was dumping serotonin into my bloodstream before the liver had a chance to clean it of the excess hormone. Once in the bloodstream, this would have impacted my brain, would it not? Maybe i am misunderstanding your explanation of the experience but it sounds to me that you are saying there are other reasons for these experiences? If so, i have to disagree, In my case there is no other explanation, I had no idea for years I had an active carcinoid tumor, my symptoms increased in severity (bouts of anger, depression, etc.,) over those years. Once located and removed my symptoms decreased/disappeared in total almost immediately. Thanks for listening.
excess serotonin from tumours in the gut do not cross the blood brain barrier. Brain and Gut serotonin are manufactured separately and remain in their own stores. I cannot comment on you situation or the context of the doctor’s explanation. Sorry
Hi Ronnie, I stumbled across your page when I got the result of my chromogranin A blood test (90), did the 5HIAA urine test (awaiting results) and hot called for an urgent Tektrotyd scan – ALL my symptoms point to a neuroendocrine tumour (I have felt ill for about 7 years). I have all the symptoms of carcinoid syndrome. However scan results are clear, no tumours. But I’m baffled – why is my CgA high and why do I feel so ill? Any advice to give? I wish you well in your journey – you are very inspiring!
I see this a lot Lisa. Unfortunately with many cancers “tissue is the issue” and to do a biopsy (currently), you need to ‘see’ a tumour to biopsy. It’s possible you don’t have a NET as the symptoms tend to be vague and similar to many everyday conditions – I would say flushing is pretty cardinal BUT it’s not like a wet hot flash you would get in menopause nor it is sweating, it’s dry as a rule of thumb. Check out my article “I bet my flush beats yours” to see the differential diagnoses for flushing. Your CgA is not actually that high – are you taking PPIs (anti acid medications) ? That will skew CgA – a blood test called Pancreastatin is better and not affected by PPIs, if that is the case. It will be useful to see the results of the octreoscan (I had to google tektroyd!). If you have working receptors, it should light up where there is an excess secretion (but even then it needs careful interpretation). Can you let me know the results when you get it? A gallium 68 PET is the newer version of octreoscan.
Thanks for your response. I have dry flushing (no sweating) triggered by alcohol, chocolate, spicy food, stress, and sometimes is so bad I get a massive drop in blood pressure, violent vomiting, diarrhoea, immense cramping pain in right side then feel dreadful and can’t eat for 2-3 days. Keep being diagnosed with IBS but am so fatigued, B12 and vitamin D deficient, joint pain, hypoglycaemic, thyroiditis, just generally been feeling very unwell past 7 years. Seeing consultant next Wednesday so will let you know what 5HIAA result was and what scans showed. Thank you so much!
I was dx’d in 2015 and Had small intestine resection. Since then my Serotonin level has been > 2000, Last test was 2250. I was wondering what the long term effects of serotonin typically are. I see things like hyper sensitivity to cold, muscle weakness, and hyper reflexivity. I have heard of Telotristat Ethyl (XERMELO) might be able to lower this. My Net Dr mentioned this back in May 2017 but my last visit in Dec 2017, made no mention of it. But did talk about PRRT and possibility of being approved early in 2018. We depend on these Net Dr’s but they are so busy, I think my Doc has been a little scattered..
Hi Jeff. What was your 5HIAA score? You didn’t mention the unit of measure for serotonin, presumably the figure you gave is not normal, i.e. it’s out of range? XERMELO is approved for inadequate control of carcinoid syndrome diarrhea (this would indicate it’s for diarrhea caused by abnormal levels of serotonin rather than caused by surgery (i.e. shorter bowel etc)). Apparently it does lower 5HIAA results (the output of serotonin). Check out my article on XERMELO https://ronnyallan.com/2016/03/31/telotristat-ethyl-xermelo-an-oral-treatment-for-carcinoid-syndrome-diarrhea-not-adequately-controlled-by-somatostatin-analogues/ I would say one of the biggest long term risks of elevated serotonin is carcinoid heart disease – https://ronnyallan.com/2015/06/02/neuroendocrine-cancer-dont-break-my-heart/ however, these risks are lowered by the use of somatostatin analogues
Really interesting. At oncology appointments I only have blood taken which is immediately put on ice. Do you think that’s the plasma version test you mention? Haven’t done a 24 hour urine for a while. Also Ronnie. What are your thoughts on fatigue? Disease vs treatment as the cause. It drives me crazy. Thanks.
https://polldaddy.com/js/rating/rating.js
The blood in ice is probably Chromogranin A (CgA) which is measuring tumour bulk rather than function. As for fatigue, am working on a post stay tuned. However, it’s a common problem and even doctors gave difficulty fixing it. I have some ideas.
What are your thoughts on discontinuing an SSRI for 72 hours prior to the 5-HIAA test? Is it necessary to do so? My GI doctor said I didn’t need to stop them, but I’ve read conflicting information. I’d rather not have to stop them if possible, but I don’t want to mess up my test results either.
https://polldaddy.com/js/rating/rating.js
Great question and a technical one. I have not seen any pre 5HIAA test instructions saying to preclude them. Going slightly technical, brain and peripheral stores of serotonin are maintained within their own areas and do not cross into each other, the blood brain barrier prevents this. https://ronnyallan.com/2016/09/08/serotonin-the-net-effect/
One of your best, Ronny. Thank you
This is good stuff. I have been wondering why I wasn’t tripping over myself with happiness if my body produces too much Serotonin and why I don’t feel more sad with my Lanreotide injections. I have been curious if this injection interferes with the 5-HTP test results? Would it also interfere with a Gallium scan’s results? Should one stop injections before such tests?
Thanks for commenting. I tried to put over that the two stores of serotonin in the GI tract and the brain were independent of each other, mainly to dispell the myth that the excess serotonin from NET tumours (specifically carcinoid) does not go zooming straight into the brain. I did not want to focus on serotonin issues associated with depression and treament for that (SSRIs etc) as it is even more technical (and beyond my understanding) and would perhaps complicate my focus on the specific serotonin NET issues, which in comparison are straightforward (kinda !).
As for somatostatin analogues leading up to a Octreotide scan or Gallium 68, there is a protocol for that which I will try to find for you. Re the 5-HTP test, why do you get this? Is it a blood serum test.
I have read that excess serotonin can also cause agitation. I immediately calmed down when my tumors were removed. Lanreotide is helping also
Do you mean brain serotonin or gut serotonin? In respect brain serotonin, excess would not be a NET issue and I wanted to avoid discussing illnesses such as serotonin syndrome as this is not related to NETS.
I suppose the agitation is from brain serotonin but it’s interesting that I feel more calm since my gut serotonin is lower. It’s still above average but lower than prior to surgery. Perhaps it’s due to some other cause.
Maybe you’re feeling more calm because you’ve had treatment? If you’re also taking a somatostatin analogue, that will lower gut serotonin too.