Incurable isn’t terminal

Translate

Opinion

Words are important

I was diagnosed with stage IV cancer in 2010.  OK, it wasn’t a really aggressive type but it had caused a lot of damage.  It’s amazing to think that someone is still adding to their stage IV cancer story after 12 years.  You can read a chronological list of what happened to me and what treatment I had (and still get) by clicking here.  

So, am I terminal?  No, in my opinion, and by any stretch of the imagination, someone who has lived with stage IV cancer for 12 years cannot be considered terminal. Let’s look at some definitions which are generally agreed with similar wording wherever you look:

Terminal Cancer

Terminal cancer refers to cancer that can’t be cured or treated. It’s sometimes also called end-stage cancer. Any type of cancer can become terminal cancer. (Note:  end stage is a synonym for terminal cancer, not the final stage in cancer staging terminology). I’m conscious that with terminal cancer there can be legal ramifications to certain definitions (wills, life insurance, disability etc) and that these may differ on an international/federal basis.  So, I chose these definitions from a couple of ‘big hitter’ and ‘authoritative’ cancer sites:

Cancer Research UK defines terminal as “When cancer is described as terminal it means that it cannot be cured and is likely to cause death within a limited period of time. The amount of time is difficult to predict but it could be weeks to several months”.

The American Cancer Society defines terminal as “an irreversible condition (it cannot be cured) that in the near future will result in death or a state of permanent unconsciousness from which you are unlikely to recover. In most states, a terminal illness is legally defined as one in which the patient will die shortly whether or not medical treatment is given.”

Advanced Cancer

Advanced cancer is different from terminal cancer. Like terminal cancer, advanced cancer isn’t curable. But it does respond to treatment, which may slow down its progression. Terminal cancer doesn’t respond to treatment. As a result, treating terminal cancer focuses on making someone as comfortable as possible. The American Cancer Society defines it as “Advanced cancer is most often used to describe cancers that cannot be cured. This means cancers that won’t totally go away and stay away completely with treatment. However, some types of advanced cancer can be controlled over a long period of time and are thought of as an ongoing (or chronic) illness.”

Incurable Cancer

Stage 4 cancer usually can’t be cured. In addition, because many cancers are not diagnosed until there are distant metastases, it is unlikely that most cases of incurable cancers can be completely removed. The goal of treatment is to prolong survival and improve your quality of life.  It follows that some advanced cancers can accurately be described as “Incurable but treatable”.  The length of time treatable will have an effect is variable and subject to many factors. 

There are always outliers in any spectrum of outcomes.

The Cancer story is changing

What I also found during my research is that as more and more people are now living with and beyond cancer (all cancers) rather than dying from it, there is a new class of patients emerging – Macmillan UK calls this “treatable but not curable” and I believe this is very relevant to Neuroendocrine Cancer.  I call it “Incurable but Treatable” but I’ve always been a disruptor (but a positive disruptor) – I just think it’s easier to say and sounds more positive.  

Click on the picture to read

Following my diagnosis in 2010, I went on to receive really good treatment and it continues to this day with Lanreotide backed up by a rigorous surveillance regime (and this is backed up by my own advocacy!).  However, I have totally accepted the fact that I have metastatic Neuroendocrine Cancer and that it cannot be cured.  By the way, I intentionally used ‘metastatic‘ rather than Stage IV.  Mention of Stage IV can set off alarm bells and send the wrong message to the recipient. I don’t believe Stage IV has the same ‘red flag’ meaning for well-differentiated NETs as it does with more aggressive cancers of the same stage. Given what I know now, I would certainly challenge any doctor who told me I had a ‘terminal disease’ and at the same time told me I had a slow growing well differentiated Neuroendocrine Cancer.

As people live longer with cancer, medical science continues to advance providing hope for better treatments to be introduced. 

I now live with this disease (….and its consequences) and do not feel like I’m dying of it.  Moreover, I most certainly do not see myself as a ‘terminal’ cancer patient, particularly as I’ve now been living with it since 2010. I like to focus on how I can live better with it.

Palliative Care

Click picture to read more

Whilst we’re on this subject, please note Palliative Care is not just end-of-life/hospice care, the scope is much wider. Read more here.

Improvements need to be made though, changing its name is a good start. 

Disclaimer

I am not a doctor or any form of medical professional, practitioner or counsellor. None of the information on my website, or linked to my website(s), or conveyed by me on any social media or presentation, should be interpreted as medical advice given or advised by me. 

Neither should any post or comment made by a follower or member of my private group be assumed to be medical advice, even if that person is a healthcare professional.   

Please also note that mention of a clinical service, trial/study or therapy does not constitute an endorsement of that service, trial/study or therapy by Ronny Allan, the information is provided for education and awareness purposes and/or related to Ronny Allan’s own patient experience. This element of the disclaimer includes any complementary medicine, non-prescription over the counter drugs and supplements such as vitamins and minerals.

Thanks for reading.

Ronny

I’m also active on Facebook. Like this page.
I’m also active on this Facebook page. Follow this page.
Also like this awareness page on Facebook. 

Sign up for my newsletters – Click Here

Disclaimer

My Diagnosis and Treatment History

Follow me on twitter

Check out my online presentations

Check out my WEGO Health Awards

Like my new awareness page – click here or on the photo.  (Like rather than follow please!)

Check out my Glossary of Terms – click here

patients included

Please Share this post for Neuroendocrine Cancer awareness and to help another patient

 
 
 
Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
WhatsApp
Email

Sometimes, you gotta climb that hill, even if it hurts

I started my “sometimes you gotta climb that hill” series/campaign some years so.  I used it as a metaphor based on my own experience of

Read More »

A spotlight on duodenal Neuroendocrine Neoplasms (dNENs)

What are Duodenal Neuroendocrine Neoplasms (dNEN)? The duodenum is technically part of the small intestine, and you can find that in most anatomy-based descriptions. One

Read More »

Neuroendocrine Cancer: Awareness is key, but it must be the right message

Let me start by saying that Neuroendocrine Cancer awareness is in a better place than it was when I was diagnosed in 2010.  But it

Read More »

Summary of May 2023 on RonnyAllan.NET

Summary May produced the best statistics in 2023, mainly due to your support for my blog post on Maria Menounos whose announcement headlined as “Pancreatic

Read More »

Getting back in the saddle

Those who follow my Facebook page Ronny Allan may remember my cycling faux pas in April causing me to bruise or fracture a rib (here

Read More »

Clinical Trial: Phase 1/2a Study of 23ME-00610 in Patients With Advanced Solid Malignancies (incl Neuroendocrine Neoplasms)

Who are 23andMe? I personally had not heard of 23andMe but many people in North America might have.  When you first look at what they

Read More »

A spotlight on Chromogranin A

What is Chromogranin A? Chromogranin A (CgA) is an acidic protein released along with catecholamines from chromaffin cells and nerve terminals. This statement alone might

Read More »

Neuroendocrine Cancer: Catch them early, not late!

Diagnosing Neuroendocrine Neoplasms (NENs). It’s no secret that Neuroendocrine Neoplasms (NENs) can be difficult to diagnose, particularly well differentiated slow growing types (NETs) which can

Read More »

A spotlight on Rectal Neuroendocrine Neoplasms

What are Rectal NENs Rectal Neuroendocrine Neoplasms (NENs) (rNENs) account for approximately 1-2% of all primary cancers in the rectum.  The other main cancer types

Read More »

5 thoughts on “Incurable isn’t terminal

  • Alan Mckissock

    Ronny as always you are very positive.Howeverwe must be careful with the words we use.There are people getting benefits as they are determined as terminal.

    • I hear you but I was very careful with the words. The context was set by the definitions and the definitions are not mine, they are authoritative sites.

      As for the 12-year thing, I said it was my opinion but the definitions seem to back up what I said. I also said, “There are always outliers in any spectrum of outcome”.

      I also said, “I’m conscious that with terminal cancer there are legal ramifications with the definitions (wills, life insurance, disability etc) and that these may differ on an international/federal basis”. I took that into account, but it does not change anything else in the blog post which is also bound by my disclaimer.

  • Keith

    I really appreciate you for sharing your story, experience, and knowledge. As champions go, you are right up there with my wife, Camille. She began to blaze our path to NETRF, NET specialists at University Iowa Holden Cancer Center and University of Chicago. Less than a month after my ultrasound and MRI and 5-10 days after the biopsy results came back PNET we were scheduled at both of these outstanding institutions. The scans showed innumerable lesions in both lobes of the liver and a primary on the tail of the pancreas. Full body scans showed no further involvement. That was early summer 2019. After 3 months on lanreotide, Dr Keutgen, the UofChi NET team leader moved us on to the medication combo CAPTEM for about a year+ which provided dramatic reductions in the primary and liver. Mid-November 2020 Dr. Keutgen, removed the primary and nearly all of the liver lesions (plus gallbladder and spleen were removed but uninvolved with disease) in a 7-8 hour surgical procedure. After 7 nights in their hospital, recovery at home was mostly steady, nearly complete by mid-January, and involved only modest pain which was managed with extra strength Acetaminophen supplemented occasionally with Tramadol and 2 nights on some stronger stuff to help make for more restful sleep.

    Today, I too have an incurable metastatic cancer – a chronic condition. The only thing in my life that I would describe as innumerable are the stacks of blessings that I have experienced every day since June 2019 and will experience for years to come.
    I keep a long written list nearby and look at it often.

    God bless and Happy Thanksgiving to all.
    Keith

  • W. Charles Morgan

    This is a great article. My case sounds very much like yours. My health is slowly deteriorating but I’m not sure it’s the cancer. Thanks for your great work.

I love comments - feel free!

%d bloggers like this:
Verified by MonsterInsights